Staten Island  ·  Manhattan  ·  New York City

Your New York City Realtorfor Renters Ready to Upgrade

Helping you own your first house, co-ops or condo.

Homeownership in NYC

I help professionals buying their first home, turn the fear of making an expensive mistake into the confidence to buy smart.

Median Home Price Range by Borough

Manhattan$825K – $1.7MCo-op $825K
Condo $1.7M
Overall median $1.1M
Brooklyn$558K – $1.4MCo-op $558K · Condo $1.2M
House $1.4M
Overall median $1.1M
Queens$341K – $970KCo-op $341K · Condo $593K
House $970K
Overall median $750K
The Bronx$280K – $790KCo-op $280K · Condo $360K
House $790K
Overall median $570K
Staten Island$536K – $760KCondo $536K
House $760K
Overall median $727K

Median sale prices by home type, August 2026. Source: PropertyShark. Cross-checked against StreetEasy borough medians. Manhattan range excludes townhouses. Staten Island co-op sales were too few in August for PropertyShark to report a median.

Maiysha Mondesi NYC Realtor
Maiysha Mondesi Licensed Real Estate Salesperson  ·  New York State

Who I Am

A Native New Yorker Who Knows This City Personally

NY State Licensed Real Estate Salesperson Brokerage: Digiulio  ·  260 W 35th St, Fl. 8, New York, NY 10001

Growing up in New York City, I was used to being close to everything. The energy, the entertainment, the people. Then, about 20 years ago, my life changed. I was newly married, pregnant, and moving to Staten Island. And honestly, this was not a move I had planned for myself.

I remember knowing that life was about to look very different. I had a child on the way, a new place to live, and a lot of unknowns in front of me. I wanted to create a good life for my family, but I didn't have a perfect plan for how I was going to do it.

I had to figure things out as I went. I wanted to make good decisions for my family, but I quickly learned that wanting to make the right decision and actually knowing what the right decision is are two different things.

That's when I realized I didn't need to have everything figured out. I needed to understand what was in front of me and make the best decision I could.

My faith and having the right people around me made a difference. I asked questions. I gathered information. I looked at my options. Little by little, I became more confident in the decisions I was making.

That experience changed the way I approach major decisions. I learned that you don't have to know everything. But you do need to understand what you're choosing. You need to ask better questions. You need good information. You need to understand the risks and possibilities. Sometimes, you need someone in your corner who can help you see what you might not see on your own.

Looking back, moving to Staten Island became an important part of my story. It wasn't the move I had planned, but it became a place where I built a life for my family. That experience is a big part of why I approach real estate the way I do today. When you're buying your first home, you may have planned for it, saved for it, and thought about it for years. But that doesn't mean you know everything that goes into making a smart purchase.

You may wonder if the neighborhood is right for you. You may question whether the price makes sense. You may wonder what you're missing beyond what you see during a showing and that's where having the right information and the right person in your corner can make a difference.

You shouldn't have to figure it all out alone. My goal is to help you buy your first home, turn the fear of making an expensive mistake into the confidence to buy smart.

Talk to Maiysha

What I Help With

Services for Renters, Buyers & Sellers

01

Luxury Rental Upgrades

Moving from a cramped rental to a building that fits your life. Concierge, in-unit laundry, gym access. I find buildings that say yes to your application.

02

Condo Buying

You want to own. I walk you through every step, from board requirements to closing. I specialize in Staten Island condos and Manhattan new developments.

03

Co-op Buying

Co-op boards are notoriously strict. I prep your application, position your financials, and guide you through board interviews so your file stands out.

04

New Development

Getting in early on Staten Island's North Shore growth. I connect buyers to pre-sales and new builds before they hit the open market.

05

Application Strategy

Your credit, income docs, and references matter. I review your profile before you apply so you walk in prepared, not rejected.

06

Home Sellers

Selling your Staten Island property and need a real strategy, not just a listing. I price it right, market it to serious buyers, and protect your timeline.

My Process

The Priority Method

Five steps that take you from “I need to move” to signed, approved, and settled.

01

Upgrade Clarity Call

We get specific about what you need, what you qualify for, and what your timeline looks like.

02

Neighborhood & Building Match

I match you to specific neighborhoods and buildings based on your income, lifestyle, and approval profile.

03

Curated Tours Only

You only see spaces that fit your criteria and budget. No wasted tours.

04

Strong Application & Smart Terms

I help you build an application that gets approved. I know what boards and landlords want to see.

05

Smooth Move & Settle-In Plan

Closing day is not the end. I make sure you're actually settled in, not just handed keys.

Local Market Data

What's Happening on Staten Island's North Shore

The North Shore of Staten Island is one of the only pockets in NYC where professionals are still finding real value. Direct ferry access to Lower Manhattan and rents well below Manhattan levels.

$400K–$600KNorth Shore Condo RangeDeFalco Realty, April 2026
~$3,000Avg 2BR Rent, Staten IslandRentHop, September 2026
25 minFerry to Manhattan — FreeNYC DOT confirmed
$550K–$800KNorth Shore Multi-Family RangeDeFalco Realty, April 2026
$400MNorth Shore Action PlanNYC, announced Sept 2023
NYCMarket ExpertiseStaten Island + Manhattan

Market data updated regularly. Contact Maiysha for current listings and neighborhood-specific pricing.

2026 Market Data

Manhattan vs. North Shore, Staten Island

Side-by-side rental data, condo and co-op prices, transit, and lifestyle. All figures verified from 2026 market reports.

Median Rent (1BR) $5,109 Manhattan
$2,500 North Shore SI
Median Condo Price $1.7M Manhattan
$400–600K North Shore SI
Median Co-op Price $870K Manhattan
$300K North Shore SI
Ferry to FiDi — Manhattan
25 min Free, 24/7

Savings

A 1-bedroom in North Shore SI averages $2,500/month vs. $5,109 in Manhattan. That is over $31,000 saved per year without leaving NYC.

Commute

The Staten Island Ferry runs 24/7 from St. George to FiDi. 25 minutes, completely free. If you work Downtown, this is a real alternative.

Buying

North Shore condos run $400K–$600K. Manhattan median condo price is $1.7M. More space, lower payments, and real equity on the table.

Detailed Comparison

Metric Manhattan North Shore, SI
Median Rent — Studio$3,525$1,800 – $2,200
Median Rent — 1 Bedroom$5,109$2,500
Median Rent — 2 Bedroom$6,095$3,000 – $3,200
Doorman Rent (Median)$5,433$2,200 – $2,800 waterfront
Median Condo Sale Price$1,700,000$400,000 – $600,000
Median Co-op Sale Price$870,000$250,000 – $350,000
Price Per Sq Ft (Condo)$2,054$400 – $480
Avg Days on Market95 – 105 days~57 days (Staten Island)
YoY Rent Change+6.5% to 7%+6% (Zumper, Sept 2026)
Transit20+ subway linesSI Ferry (free, 24/7) + SIR + Express Buses
Commute to FiDiWalking / 1–3 stops25 min free ferry
Broker Fee (FARE Act 2025)Landlord-paidLandlord-paid

Choose Manhattan If You…

  • +Work in midtown or uptown and need to be minutes away
  • +Want luxury doorman buildings with concierge, gym, and rooftop all in one place
  • +Have a budget of $4,500+ per month for a comfortable 1-bedroom
  • +Prefer a co-op and can handle the board process
  • +Want the NYC energy right outside your door every single day

Choose North Shore, SI If You…

  • +Work in Lower Manhattan or FiDi and can use the free 25-min ferry
  • +Want significantly more space for $1,700–$2,500/month instead of $5,000+
  • +Are ready to stop renting and want condo entry points starting at $400K
  • +Want waterfront views, a quieter pace, and real storage space
  • +Are watching a neighborhood grow and want to be positioned early

Frequently Asked Questions

Is North Shore Staten Island really cheaper than Manhattan? +

Yes, significantly. A 1-bedroom in St. George averages $2,500/month. A comparable Manhattan unit runs $5,109. That is over $2,600/month in savings — roughly $31,300 per year back in your pocket.

How long is the commute from St. George to Manhattan? +

The Staten Island Ferry runs 24/7 from St. George to Whitehall Street in FiDi — 25 minutes, completely free. If you work Downtown, the commute is often faster than living in parts of Brooklyn or Queens. For Midtown, typically 45–55 minutes door to door.

What is the difference between a condo and a co-op in NYC? +

With a condo, you own your unit outright. Financing is easier (10–20% down) and subletting is more flexible. With a co-op, boards require larger down payments (20%+), detailed financial review, and personal interviews. North Shore SI has limited co-op inventory, so buyers there typically work with condos.

Do I still pay a broker fee in NYC in 2026? +

Under the FARE Act (effective June 11, 2025), if the landlord hired the broker, the landlord pays the fee. This applies in both Manhattan and Staten Island. We walk you through exactly what fees apply to your situation before you sign anything.

Is North Shore Staten Island a good investment right now? +

Multiple signals say yes. About 43% of households in the St. George/Stapleton district rent, which keeps demand steady (NYU Furman Center, 2024). The North Shore Action Plan and Lighthouse Point development are adding real value. Condo prices still run $400K–$600K while the rest of NYC trades much higher.

1st Time Home Buyer Q&A

How much do I actually need for a down payment? +

Less than people think. FHA loans start at 3.5%. Conventional loans can go as low as 3% for first timers. It's not always the 20% everyone assumes.

What's my monthly payment really going to look like? +

Mortgage is just one piece. You've got taxes, insurance, and in a condo or co-op, monthly common charges or maintenance. Ask for the full number, not just principal and interest.

Do I need perfect credit to buy? +

No. You need a decent score, not a perfect one. Most first time buyers get approved with a 620 or higher, and some programs go lower.

What's the difference between a co-op and a condo? +

A condo means you own real property. A co-op means you own shares in a corporation that owns the building. Co-ops have board approval and stricter rules. Condos are usually easier to get into but cost more.

How long does the whole buying process take? +

From offer to closing, usually 60 to 90 days. Co-ops can take longer because of board packages and interviews.

What's earnest money and do I get it back? +

It's a deposit that shows you're serious once your offer is accepted. It gets credited toward your purchase at closing. You only lose it if you walk away for a reason not covered in your contract.

Should I get pre-approved before I start looking? +

Yes, every time. A pre-approval tells you your real budget and makes sellers take your offer seriously. Without it, you're just window shopping.

What hidden costs surprise people the most? +

Closing costs. Attorney fees, transfer taxes, title insurance, mansion tax if your purchase is over a million. Budget an extra 2 to 5% on top of your down payment.

How do I know if I'm overpaying? +

Comps. What sold in that building or block in the last 3 to 6 months tells you the real story, not the asking price.

What should I actually look for during a showing? +

Noise level, natural light, storage, and building condition. Anyone can stage a living room. You're checking for what you'll live with every day.

Do I need a real estate attorney? +

In New York, yes. It's not optional here like it is in a lot of other states. Your attorney reviews the contract and protects you.

What if I find something I love but I'm not ready to buy yet? +

That happens. It's better to know your numbers first so when the right place shows up, you can move fast instead of scrambling.

How competitive is the market right now? +

Depends on the price point and neighborhood. Good units in the right range still move fast. That's why prep matters more than luck.

Will I be able to sell this place easily down the road? +

That depends on location, building type, and how you buy now. A smart purchase today protects your resale value later.

What happens after I close, is that it? +

No. Moving logistics, insurance, address changes, and settling in are their own project. A good agent doesn't disappear at the closing table.

Sources: Douglas Elliman / Miller Samuel rental report Jan 2026 & Aug 2026; Corcoran June 2026; Coldwell Banker Warburg Q2 2026; PropertyShark Aug 2026; Zumper & RentHop Sept 2026; Robert DeFalco Realty April 2026; NYU Furman Center 2024.

Get In Touch

Tell me where you are and where you want to go. We will talk through your options in 30 minutes or less.

Connect With Maiysha

Brokerage

Digiulio  ·  260 W 35th St, Fl. 8, New York, NY 10001

Service Area

New York City

Send a Message

Serving: St. George · Stapleton · New Brighton · Tompkinsville · Clifton · Rosebank · Randall Manor · West Brighton · Port Richmond · Mariners Harbor · Castleton Corners · Financial District · Tribeca · Lower Manhattan · Midtown · Upper East Side · Upper West Side · Harlem